Wednesday, January 25, 2012

Email 1162, June 2007: Eugene Wahl says the Ammann-Wahl paper can be freely shared among warmists before it comes out in hardcopy, but it should be kept away from McIntyre

Email 1162

Here is the Ammann-Wahl paper as promised. We received letter of final acceptance and movement to "in press" status yesterday from Stephen Schneider. We would ask that distribution be kept limited until it actually comes out in hard copy (scheduled for the November 2007 issue of Climatic Change) so that its chances of getting to McIntyre (et al.) are reduced, and thus the the probability is decreased that he/they will have chance to attack it before it is fully available to the public--as they almost certainly would if the opportunity arises. Weird to need to consider such things, but that is the state of our science re: this particular paper.

However, you should certainly feel free to share it within your research groups.

Peace, Gene Dr. Eugene R. Wahl


LuboŇ° Motl said...

That's pretty amazing, too. It's not paranoia if they're really going after you. ;-)

Robert Austin said...

Makes sense if you know your paper has problems and bloodhound Steve McIntyre will sniff out the flaws before you can say "the science is settled".