Friday, July 18, 2008

I Guess It Got Lost in the Mail

Climate Audit - by Steve McIntyre » I Guess It Got Lost in the Mail
A Climate Audit reader in Australia drew CSIRO’s attention to criticism of their data stonewalling here at CA. CSIRO promptly told the Australian reader that the “appropriate CSIRO climate scientists and Communications team have responded accordingly to Stephen McIntyre and David Stockwell directly, in order to address their concerns” and that “some of the direct responses have even been posted on the www.climateaudit.org website”.

Well, for the record, they haven’t responded to me “directly” in the sense that anyone from CSIRO actually sent me an email of any sort and, to the extent that they are claiming to be responding to my particular criticisms, it is untrue that “some of the direct responses have even been posted on the www.climateaudit.org website”.
...
Why would CSIRO send out a response where the particulars are not merely untrue but the inaccuracy of which can be easily checked? Maybe they used someone from the Team as a fact checker.

No comments: