Saturday, September 27, 2008

Scary "Reality" of Climate Situation Not Getting Through « La Marguerite
“Next year, when my youngest daughter goes to college, I wouldn’t mind spending more time in Hawaii” I mused over dinner with my friends Tom and Betsy. And quickly added that I felt conflicted about the idea. Given the climate situation, I told them, it felt irresponsible to engage in such gratuitous behavior. Both of my friends looked at me as if I was some crazy woman. Why wouldn’t I want to fly to Hawaii? No way would they change their habit of flying to Europe three of four times a year. Tom started ranting about not subscribing to moralistic attitudes towards climate change. No, the solution lied in new technologies. What about all the predictions that keep getting worse and worse? I asked. Tom, an engineer with an interest in data visualization, expressed skepticism. There is a lot we don’t know. All those data are to be taken with a grain of salt. No, both he and Betsy were adamant they were not about to change their lifestyle, one bit. I was shocked. And changed subject.

2 comments:

Marguerite Manteau-Rao said...

I am honored to be featured on your blog :)

Just answer one thing for me, will you? What do you and your climate naysayer friends have to gain from your relentless denial of the scientific truth? It would not matter if the stakes were not so high.

I am just puzzled by such an attitude and would love to hear how you got to such a place.

Anonymous said...

"What do you and your climate naysayer friends have to gain from your relentless denial"

I can't speak for Tom Nelson, but for me, I have nothing (personally) to gain from being a "denier" except the satisfaction which comes from thinking rationally and critically.

I have studied things carefully and I am reasonably satisfied that CAGW is a hoax. I have laid out my reasons on my blog:

brazil84.wordpress.com

Feel free to debate me there. I promise to consider your argument with an open mind.