Sunday, June 07, 2009

Where's the evidence that CO2 is destroying the US maple syrup industry?

1. March '07: New York Times runs typical sob story about the allegedly devastating effect of carbon dioxide on the Vermont maple syrup industry: "Warm Winters Upset Rhythms of Maple Sugar" - New York Times
“You might be tempted to say, well that’s a bunch of baloney — global warming,” said Mr. Morse, drilling his first tap holes this season in mid-February, as snow hugged the maples and Vermont braced for a record snowfall. “But the way I feel, we get too much warm. How many winters are we going to go with Decembers turning into short-sleeve weather, before the maple trees say, ‘I don’t like it here any more?’
2. June '09: Daily Kos again promotes the notion in #1 above: Global Hunger is a Global Warming Issue
As I write that title, two memories come to mind. A year or so ago, I ordered pancakes with real maple syrup at a restaurant. As my order came, Hekebolos remarked "Enjoy American maple syrup while it still exists." It's no longer news that climate change means that areas that used to have cold enough winters to produce maple syrup might now be too warm.
Ok, so how were real maple syrup crops in Vermont in 2007, 2008, and 2009?

3. StopGlobalWarming.org: [An admission of a bumper maple syrup crop in 2007]
[Vermont, 2007] Mr. Crocker's total crop, produced through April 20, was 6,100 gallons, just 120 gallons below his best year ever.
4. From the comment section here: [A report of very good Northeast maple syrup crops in 2008 and 2009] | Yahoo! Green
Posted by ericstocks Wed Apr 15, 2009 2:49pm PDT

Well, last year (2008) was like the "storm of the century" for Maple Syrup production in the Northeast. We couldn't even keep up - temps were perfect. We quit before the weather did. 2009 was also a really good year, having just ended. Beautiful syrup and lots of it. These reporters don't know jack.
5. And it's not just the Northeast: Bumper Wisconsin maple syrup crop in '09 - Chicago Tribune
Associated Press
April 06, 2009
WAUSAU, Wis. -

Higher prices and a strong sap run have Wisconsin’s maple syrup producers feeling hopeful this season.

Joe Polak is a third-generation maple syrup producer and co-owner of Maple Hollow in Merrill. He says the sap has run and run this spring, giving him one of the best crops he’s had in a long time.

No comments: