WASHINGTON -- When former NASA administrators, astronauts and engineers
released a letter earlier this week attacking the science of climate change, its veneer of legitimacy kicked off a media blitz. Yet none of the letter's 49 signatories are climate scientists, and with more than 18,000 people currently working for NASA, to say nothing of the tens of thousands more who are retired, the letter seems more than anything like a empty publicity stunt -- for which there's considerable precedent.
"This is an old stunt," explained Michael Mann, a well-known climate scientist and Penn State professor. "When you have an area of the science where there is a consensus like in climate change, where the problem is real and the scientific implications are on a collision course with vested interests like the fossil fuel industry, you often see this." [What other areas of science is Mann talking about?]
..."They can't discredit the science in the legitimate sphere of scientific debate, which is to say, the peer-reviewed literature, the various assessment reports published by various governments ... so what they try to do is create the illusion that the science is being hotly contested by finding the small group,
often of curmudgeonly individuals, who might feel left out," said Mann, who documents this recurrent phenomenon in his newly released book, "The Hockey Stick And The Climate Wars: Dispatches From The Front Lines."
Author John Cook
similarly considers such public announcements as one of the five most easily identifiable characteristics of science denialism, wherein deniers use fake experts to undermine established science.
...Of course, two can play at enlisting the support of false experts.
Mann -- who, having survived the
phony Climategate scandal, has as much experience as anyone in fighting off the political attacks of climate deniers -- offered a bit of media bait of his own.
"What's really telling is that they couldn't get people like Buzz Aldrin -- or for that matter John Glenn -- to sign this petition," Mann said. "I think it speaks volumes that the most prominent astronauts were completely uninterested in having any part in this ploy, and I was proud of them for that."
1 comment:
There are 3 categories of climate change sceptics - 1. Climate change is not happening. 2. Climate change is happening but humans aren't to blame. 3. Climate change is happening, humans are largely to blame but we shouldn't be taking any drastic measures to counter it. Based on what Aldrin is saying here I would put him in category 3. He doesn't deny change nor does he come out and say that human activity isn't causing climate change , he simply appears to be saying that extraordinary efforts to counteract this change are not called for.
Post a Comment