Email 2590, Sept 2005, Rosanne D'Arrigo after McIntyre asked to see the data from her paper that was referenced by the IPCC: "they should fire him as a reviewer of IPCC"

Email 2590

date: Wed, 28 Sep 2005 10:37:37 -0400 from: "Rosanne D'Arrigo" subject: Re: Fw: D'Arrigo et al, submitted to: Tim Osborn

hi Rob -

i am leary of passing all of this around but in this case i am glad in that osborn et al need to know what is going on - they should fire him as a reviewer of IPCC - i cant believe they included him in the first place! So, please email him back and tell him that he should as he says take it up with the ipcc authors and see whether it is still appropriate to include him as a reviewer.

we should however be very cautious about our emails, lord v will stop at nothing (this is sort of fun in a harry potter way)...

R